For $55, get a punch card for 12 loaves of fresh bread (up to $5.95 in value). Use all 12 at once, or redeem once a month for a year, or shop in for a loaf at any interval you choose.
We specialize in breads made with freshly-milled flour that we grind daily on site. We seek out the best local grain we can find. Grown by a multi-generation farming family near Penn Yan, New York, the organic grain has distinctive terroir.
Grassy, creamy, nutty, this is what NYS grain tastes like.
By adding only the simplest ingredients like water, salt, and sometimes eggs and butter to our loaves, we respect the flavor of the grain and let it shine.
We hope that you enjoy our assorted varieties of traditional and naturally-leavened European-inspired breads.
Details and conditions: Vouchers can be redeemed for loaves up to $5.95 in value in our bake shop based on availability of loaves. A less expensive loaf can be selected, but no change or credit will be given. If you'd like a premium loaf, you can use your punch card and pay the difference.
Vouchers do not have an expiration date. Should we cease selling vouchers, they will be valid for a year after their sale date, after which they will be exchanged at our discretion. Vouchers may not be transferred to others. Lost cards will not be replaced. Unused cards cannot be redeemed for cash or credit.
Millers Thumb Bakery & Café
258 Highland Parkway, Tonawanda, NY 14223
Copyright © 2026 Millers Thumb Bakery & Café - All Rights Reserved.

Please subscribe to our newsletter for information about our menu of baked goods and savory fare, event and class announcements, and more.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.