miller's thumb bakery & cafe

miller's thumb bakery & cafe miller's thumb bakery & cafe miller's thumb bakery & cafe
  • home
  • hours & info
  • cafe menu
  • monthly bread schedule
  • catering
  • More
    • home
    • hours & info
    • cafe menu
    • monthly bread schedule
    • catering

miller's thumb bakery & cafe

miller's thumb bakery & cafe miller's thumb bakery & cafe miller's thumb bakery & cafe
  • home
  • hours & info
  • cafe menu
  • monthly bread schedule
  • catering

Serving WNY's Favorite Bakes

Fresh Baked, Always

The old adage "worth a miller's thumb" refers to a purveyor who is not only honest, but provides superior quality milled grains. A miller tests flour by holding it on the fingers and running a thumb across. Millers attentive to quality would make this motion dozens and dozens of times a day, causing their thumbs to become flat and misshapen. We believe that the best and freshest flour becomes the best and freshest bread and pastries.   

Artisan Breads & Bagels

Artisan Breads & Bagels

Artisan Breads & Bagels

Assorted varieties of traditional and naturally-leavened European-inspired breads and bagels daily

Delightful Pastries

Artisan Breads & Bagels

Artisan Breads & Bagels

Rotating selections including croissant, kouign-amann, scone, cinnamon rolls, morning buns, seasonal danish, cookies and more 

Enjoy Café All Day

Artisan Breads & Bagels

Enjoy Café All Day

Try fresh, seasonal sandwiches and salads for a quick meal or platters and boards for your catering needs 

258 Highland Parkway  

Tonawanda, New York 14223

 hello@millersthumbbakery.com 

(716) 364-6362 

Millers Thumb Bakery & Café

258 Highland Parkway, Tonawanda, NY 14223

Copyright © 2026 Millers Thumb Bakery & Café - All Rights Reserved.

Get our free newsletter

Please subscribe to our newsletter for information about our menu of baked goods and savory fare, event and class announcements, and more. 

Subscribe Today

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept